Trust Games

To trust someone implies taking some risk. To be trustworthy implies that you will try to reduce risks to those who trust you even if it is costly to you to do so. For economists trust reduces the transaction cost of trading. In,

Berg, Joyce, John Dickhaut, and Kevin McCabe, "Trust, Reciprocity, and Social History," Games and Economic Behavior, (10)1995, pp. 122-142,

We designed an experiment to study individuals' propensity to be trusting and to be trustworthy in a task we call the investment game. In this game two subjects are each given $10 as a show up fee. One of the subjects is told that he or she will be decision maker one (DM1), and can send any amount (all, none, or some) of the $10 to the other subject (decision maker two, DM2). The rules are simple. Every dollar sent will be tripled by the experimenter before it reaches DM2, who then gets to decide how much of the tripled money to keep and how much to send back to DM1. After DM2’s decision the game is over and subjects leave. We designed the experiment so it was double-blind meaning that neither the subjects, nor the experimenter, new who was matched together, or what subject made what decision. Game theory predicts that as long as DM2 prefers more money to less, DM2 should keep all the money that is sent. Of course, DM1 should then send nothing. But this is now what happened. On average DM1’s send over $5 and roughly one third of the DM2’s reciprocated by sending back more than was originally sent even though the double-blind condition implied no one would know what DM2 really did.

Comments

[Scott N]

Isn't this how we are raised. We are taught from a very young age to trust people. We are also raised to believe that when you do something nice to someone, something nice will happen to you. We also put value on things. $10 you didn't earn, but have a chance to make a return on, wouldn't be valuable to most people. Would the results differ if you gave DM1 $10,000?

[norak uong]

Do you think that the rational self-interest assumption, which is fundamental to economics, actually causes people to be selfish? If policymakers, lawmakers, etc treat people as if they were all selfish, then for a citizen to assimilate in a world in which they are expected to be selfish, they have to be selfish.

[Hannes Kvaran]

Did I get this right? 2/3 of the DM1s lost money due to their foolish trust in DM2?

Do you have a more detailed breakdown of the responses?

Hannes Kvaran

[Will]

I don't think they lost money because of the multiplier. Presumably both DM1 & DM2 increased their funds,

Will

[chess]

put sum trust games on then

[Zack Lynch]

Kevin,

You don't need to post this, but you have a small typo in this post... 'now' should be 'not'.

.....Of course, DM1 should then send nothing. But this is now what happened.

Zack

[Reigan]

this is no help what so ever get some help!

[kylie]

u suck this is no help try getting some pro help buddy bouys and i was trying to find games!!!! put some games on it

[Kevin H]

I recently participated in an experiment exactly like the one mentioned above. I had no prior knowledge to the trust game, nor did I have any background in studying game theory. As DM1, I sent all 10 dollars to DM2, hoping that we could each make $15 off of it. I was surprised, however, to receive all $30 back (DM2 left with only their $10 show-up fee).

Perhaps this case illustrates a belief that one should not accept gifts or take what was not theirs, even when offered free from social consequence.

[laptop battery]

http://www.batterylaptoppower.com/toshiba/pa3010u.htm toshiba pa3010u battery ,

[Patio Designs]

Forever Driveways UK offers block brick paving patio designs, rustic patio designs, stone concrete patio designs, flagging and pattern imprinted concrete for concrete driveways or pressed concrete drives. We are professional driveway block paving restoration service in UK. Visit site http://www.foreverdriveways.co.uk

[Genuine Dyson Spares Parts]

Dyson Doctor UK provides genuine Dyson spares, Dyson parts, Dyson vacuum cleaners spares parts, Dyson repair replacement vacuum cleaner parts with all types of spare parts repairing for Dyson. Visit site http://www.dysondoctor.com

[Pregnancy Books Gifts Videos]

Pregnancy books and videos UK offers best pregnancy birth guides, pregnancy gifts, pre conception products, pregnancy week by week calendars, best baby name books and infant toddler books at most discount rates online. Take a pick from famous pregnancy books, pregnancy videos, cd’s, dvd’s and all products of pregnancy and children care. Visit site http://www.pregnancybooksandvideos.co.uk

[Tropical Aquarium Heaters Supplies]

Leading supplier of tropical aquariums, garden pond equipments, aquarium heaters, marine products, nishikoi staple fish food, pond liners, aquatics products and other aquarium supplies in UK. Visit site http://www.aquatics-direct.co.uk

[Clock Watch Repair Services]

Mistal clock and watch repair restoration services provide clock repair services and watch repair services for old and branded watches like Omega watch repair, Seiko watch repair, Rolex watch repair, Armani watch repair, Timex watch repair, antique clock repair, cuckoo clock repair etc. Visit site http://www.mistal.co.uk

[Structural Design Services]

Expert civil engineer structural design services UK conducting building surveys, contaminated land investigations, reinforced concrete designs, sewer drains and highway constructions etc. Site investigation consultants and subsidence report professionals also providing geotechnical foundation and steelwork analysis online. Visit site http://www.carleydaines.co.uk

[Outdoor Camping Equipment Suppliers UK]

We are the leading suppliers of outdoor camping equipment in UK. We provide camping stoves, regatta clothing, hiking boots, sleeping bags, coloman tents, gelert tents and other camping equipment supplies at massive discount prices. Visit site http://www.singersoutdoors.co.uk

[Diamond Jewellery]

Shop for diamond rings, diamond bracelets, diamond pendant necklaces, diamond bangles, diamond earrings, diamond engagement rings, diamond wedding rings and other diamond jewellery from Diamond Jewellery Direct UK. Visit site http://www.diamondjewellerydirect.co.uk

[Mobile phone covers UK]

Mobile phone covers and mobile accessories UK for brands like Nokia, Siemens, Motorola, Samsung, Ericsson and Sagem. Choose from a range of phone covers that best suits your mobile model. Visit site http://www.thephonecovershop.co.uk

[Luxury bath towels UK]

Shop for luxury towels and bed linen. We are leading bed linen suppliers in UK providing luxury bed linen and quality luxury towels and bathrobes suitable for the corporate, leisure and hospitality sectors. Visit site http://www.decotex.co.uk

[Aquarium Product Supplies]

Aquatics online is the leading supplier of tropical aquarium accessories, lighting, pond pumps, aquarium tank equipment, filters, heaters, liners and other aquarium products in UK. Visit site http://www.aquatics-online.co.uk

[Web Site Design and Development]

PimDesign is a web site design and development company based in Manchester UK offering web development, website design, search engine marketing services, pay per click advertising (PPC), search engine optimisation (SEO) and search engine promotion for online businesses. Visit site http://www.pimdesign.com

[Contemporary Diamond Earrings]

Richard Anthony's jewellery shop have beautiful collection of lovelinks jewellery, signet rings, contemporary diamond earrings, sterling silver earrings, necklaces and pendants, bangles and bracelets, rotary, mark echo and citizen eco-drive watches at the best price. Visit site http://www.richard-anthony.com

[Reptile Foods and Reptile Books]

Reptiles Online UK is a leading retailer of reptile product supplies, books and foods for all species of reptiles. We stock a full range of vivariums, terrariums, tanks, caves, heating lamps, lighting equipments and other reptile accessories. Visit site http://www.reptiles-online.com

[Luxury Ladies Bathrobe]

The bathrobe company - Bathrobe.co.uk presents you the world's finest quality bathrobes with the best selection of luxury cotton bathrobes, ladies bathrobe, towel bathrobe, hooded bathrobe, personalized bath robes for mens and womens. Visit site http://www.bathrobe.co.uk