Schools Using Money for Incentives

Recent articles in the front page of the Washington Post 8/22/2008 and the Business Day section of the New York Times 8/20/2008 both are talking about paying students to perform.  So results so far in NY to incentivize performance on AP exams are mixed.  I suspect there is not too much surprise there.  It looks like the incentives were offered after students had chosen to take the classes and they get paid once.  I remember this was an old debate when I was in graduate school between economists and psychologists on this topic.  Economists want to design incentive compatible mechanisms that either use selection or shift goals to improve performance.  Psychologists wonder how this affects the incentives that are already in play.  Well recently there has been a lot of attention on this using contingent management mechanisms to treat addictions.  A nice article by Higgins and Petry looks at alcoholism.  In these contexts paying people to stay sober and attend meetings seems to work.  I thank Warren Bickel for introducing me to this research a few years back.  In some ways the DC program looks more like contingent management paying students for attendance as an attempt to reinforce good behavior.  This is an important element that has been mostly lost on economists.  That frequency of reward matters.  They get the contingency part.  But more important, once you get kids in school what do you do with them?  If they aren't engaged how has this helped much?  In fact they may quickly learn in school strategies that are more rewarding than paying attention.  I like the quote by Benjamin Franklin that sits in my office.  "Tell me and I forget.  Teach me and I remember.  Involve me and I learn." So this raises a nice question how is involvement reinforcing?  So in the end I think both economists and psychologists need to work together on this one.  Contingent management, or monetary incentives, can help fix incentives in the short run, but involvement fixes them in the long run.   

Comments

[sayen]

This approach has much potential.In the USA, there is a doctor paying obese patients a dollar for each pound of weight lost.It works. For the latter I guess the reward is psychological.Winning a prize is fun no matter the actual value. For the developing world the “prize” is much more tacit: basic human goods.In the USA somewhere, high school students are giving $50 for earning a high grade.

This approach is capitalism at its best given funding. I’d think philanthropists would jump on board if they knew it was effective aid, because it allows one to cherry pick recipients and applications.

[Troy Camplin]

I thought about this and discussed it over on my own blog. It seems to me that so long as you are paying for outcome, it will work. There was a proposal in Georgia to pay students to go to tutoring, which I thought was a bad idea. They don't have to actually do anything or learn anything once there. But if you payed for A's, people would go to tutoring for free, I think we should in fact step it up and pay more for harder classes. And then offer harder classes.

[Dalam Hensi]

Amazing article!The storys of this blog are awsome.Thanks for all that work!Nice team!

[Kindle]

In my opinion, their ways in giving incentives is kind of odd given that most incentives are not in the form of money.

[Jobs]

It isn't that bad if you look at it from a different angle. Nice post you have there hope to read more of your posts soon.

[healthguard]

As long as you have the right funds to make it happen then go and do it.

[Monica]

Prof. Roland Fryer and his team are coducting similar research.
http://www.edlabs.harvard.edu/

[Dan Green]

Yes.Good job on this one.Like the artice!

[Ven]

Our expectations are high when we get the kids into school and its purely dependent on the nature/style of education. I completely agree with that statement, "Involve me and I learn". Kids should involve in education so that they learn better. We don't know, how many schools are making the kids to Involve ? God only knows !

Thanks.